Board Performance · 2024
In this section12 topics
- Prevention of Conflicts of Interest3 items
- Prevention of the Use of Inside Information3 items
- Anti-Corruption4 items
- Whistleblowing3 items
- Selection of Directors & Chief Executives5 items
- Selection of Independent Directors2 items
- Evaluation of Board & Subcommittee Performance3 items
- Subcommittees1 item
- Meeting Attendance & Remuneration2 items
- Supervision of Subsidiaries & Associated Companies4 items
- Board Duty Performance — Overview1 item
- Audit Committee Duty Performance1 item
Prevention of Conflicts of Interest
Has the Company Acted to Prevent Conflicts of Interest?
Yes
Operations in the Past Year
Each member of the Subsidiary’s Board shall manage any Related Parties, so as to avoid any conflicts of interest. If a conflict of interests occurs, the member in question must inform the Chairperson of the Subsidiary’s Board. Members of the Subsidiary’s Board are obliged to abstain from proceedings, when matters are discussed that have a bearing on their personal interests or those of a closely associated individual or legal entity, or if it could reasonably be assumed that such interests could influence the relevant Subsidiary board member's decisions. Transactions between the Subsidiary, Associated Company and any board member, or Related Parties of any board member, shall require approval by its Board of Directors. The Subsidiary’s board members are requested to observe a ‘silent period’ practice, implemented by the Company.
Number of Conflict-of-Interest Cases
| Metric | Current Year | Previous Year | Two Years Ago |
|---|---|---|---|
| Total number of cases or issues related to conflicts of interest (cases) | 0 | 0 | 0 |
Prevention of the Use of Inside Information
Has the Company Acted to Prevent the Use of Inside Information?
Yes
Operations in the Past Year
Conflict of Interest Prevention
• Exercise reasonable care, in good faith, for the best interests of the Company, to avoid conflicts of interest.
• Provide Directors, Senior Management, and relevant Employees with guidance on appropriately safe guarding against conflicts of interest, and on the prohibition of the use of insider information.
• Implement a due diligence process for newly on boarded members of the Board of Directors, and Senior Management, which includes a comprehensive questionnaire about potential conflicts.
• Have directors periodically carry out due diligence on the potential for any conflicts of interest, and report findings to the Company Secretary.
• Ensure the preparation of Company financial reports is subject to sufficient internal controls, to prevent unauthorized use of insider information.
• Enforce a one-month period of restriction, applicable to all directors, senior management and staff, who have access to the Company’s Insider Information, prohibiting the trading of Company securities, before public disclosure of the financial statement.
• Require Directors and Senior Management to report any trading transaction of Company securities to the Board, and any change in Company securities holdings, according to the SEC’s regulations.
• Ensure compliance with relevant SET legislation and regulations, before making Related Party Transactions, and with disclosure of interest obligations, involving unavoidable conflict of interest transactions.
• Conduct all necessary notification obligations, as soon as practicable, pursuant to a director becoming aware of a conflict of interest, in compliance with SEC Thailand rules and regulations.
Number of Inside-Information Cases
| Metric | Current Year | Previous Year | Two Years Ago |
|---|---|---|---|
| Total number of cases or issues related to the use of inside information to seek benefits (cases) | 0 | 0 | 0 |
Anti-Corruption
Has the Company Acted on Anti-Corruption?
Yes
Operations in the Past Year
• The Company is wholly dedicated to conducting business with integrity, maintaining a strong sense of responsibility towards society and stakeholders, and to promoting ethical practices, in accordance with TOG Corporate Governance principles, as well as the internationally recognized the Ten Principles of the UN Global Compact.
• Management conducts regular compliance reviews of the TOG Business Code of Conduct and Ethical Standards, and the Supplier Code of Conduct, to facilitate continuous improvement, implement preventive measures, and take corrective actions, to prevent recurrence of violation to any Code.
Management consistently engages with Sub-Committees to address pertinent matters related to compliance with the Codes, and furnishes a
comprehensive report to the Board for supervision and guidance.
• The Company educates all employees, through orientation program, to acquire awareness of our Anti-Corruption Policy, TOG Business Code of Conduct and Ethical Standards, Supplier Code of Conduct, and relevant rules of engagement, to combat bribery and corruption in all business activities, and to ensure correct decisions are made in operating the business.
• The Company encourages business partners to commit to adhering to every aspect of the Supplier Code of Conduct, and to promptly report any instances of bribery, demands, or violations of the Code, through our whistleblowing channel.
• The Company joined the Collective Action Coalition (CAC) against Corruption in the Private Sector, Thailand on 25th February 2014 and continuously renews the certificates, declaring and demonstrating our commitment to fighting all manner of corruption.
• Anti-Corruption Policy : https://www.thaiopticalgroup.com/uploads/ckeditor/files/Anti-Corruption%20EN%20%20(20-5-24).pdf
Form of Anti-Corruption Operations
| Operation |
|---|
| Review of appropriateness in anti-corruption |
| The participation in anti-corruption projects |
| Assessment and identification of corruption risk |
| Communication and training for employees on anti-corruption policy and guidelines |
| The monitoring of the evaluation of compliance with the anti- corruption policy |
| Review of the completeness and adequacy of the process by the Audit Committee or auditor |
Number of Corruption Cases
| Metric | Current Year | Previous Year | Two Years Ago |
|---|---|---|---|
| Total number of cases or issues related to corruption (cases) | 0 | 0 | 0 |
Whistleblowing
Has the Company Implemented Whistleblowing Procedures?
Yes
Operations in the Past Year
The communications channel for stakeholders raising concerns, complaints, violations or non-compliance, with any code of conduct, ethics or human rights, is open and available via :
• Email : hotline@thaiopticalgroup.com
• Sealed letter: to be sent to the Internal Audit Office or the Audit Committee at
Thai Optical Group Public Company Limited,
No.15/5 Moo 6, Bangbuathong-Suphanburi Road,
Laharn, Bangbuathong, Nonthaburi 11110, Thailand.
The Company has active procedures in place, to enhance whistleblower protection, having anonymous reporting mechanisms to protect privacy. Information is only disclosed to those within the organization, who are designated to handle such matters, or to external parties, if required by law.
Number of Whistleblowing Cases
| Metric | Current Year | Previous Year | Two Years Ago |
|---|---|---|---|
| Total number of cases or issues received through whistleblowing channels (cases) | 0 | 0 | 0 |
Selection of Directors & Chief Executives
Are Directors Selected Through the Nomination Committee?
Yes
Are Chief Executives Selected Through the Nomination Committee?
Yes
Number of Directors from Major Shareholders
0
Rights of Minority Shareholders on Director Appointment
Proposal for Nominating a Directorship Candidate:
To nominate a candidate for the directorship, eligible shareholders are required to complete the "Candidate for Directorship Nomination Form" and provide supporting shareholder documentation. The candidate must submit their personal details, curriculum vitae, and any relevant supporting documents. In cases where multiple shareholders jointly nominate a candidate, each shareholder must individually complete and sign their own form. All completed forms should then be collected and submitted as a single comprehensive set.
The Nomination and Remuneration Committee will conduct a thorough due diligence inquiry into the candidate’s background and carry out a selection interview. This process is intended to ensure the efficiency of the Committee's review before making a recommendation to the Board of Directors for consideration. If the Board of Directors agrees that the nominated candidate possesses the required qualifications to serve as a director of the Company, the Board will include this candidate in the election and appointment of directors’ agenda at the Annual General Meeting (AGM).
Qualifications for the Company's Shareholders:
Shareholders of the company must hold their shares continuously for at least 12 months from the date they intend to make a proposal and must also retain ownership of these shares on the date of the AGM. To be eligible to propose agenda items or nominate director candidates, shareholders must hold at least 5 percent of the total voting rights, whether individually or collectively.
Additionally, if the shareholder’s name does not appear on the Record Date, the Company reserves the right to exclude the proposal from the Shareholders' Meeting agenda. This action can be taken, regardless of whether these items have been included in the notice of the Annual General Meeting of Shareholders.
Method of Director Appointment
| Method |
|---|
| Method whereby each director requires approval votes more than half of the votes of attending shareholders with voting rights |
Selection of Independent Directors
Criteria for Selecting Independent Directors
Director Nomination Criteria and Process
• The Board shall comprise a diversity of genders, age-groups, and nationalities to create an inclusive Board, which reflects broader stakeholder interests, and ensures a balanced and mixed skill set of expertise, as well as relevant work experience in the Company's business industry. The Board composition shall be able to understand the business context and overall linkage of business processes, as well as bring other experience and perspectives, to foster positive relationships with stakeholders, provide effective oversight, recommend corporate governance practices, and provide useful guidance to the Senior Management, to best serve the Company’s business goals and strategies.
• In the best interests of the Company, the Board annually reviews the current effectiveness of each director, when nominating candidates for election or re-election at the time of term rotation. The Nomination & Remuneration Committee and the Board understand the importance of the Board’s effectiveness, and strive to maintain an appropriate balance of tenure, diversity, professional experience and background, skills and education, on the Board, at all times. While longer-tenured directors are familiar with the business, operations, history, policies, objectives, and contribute to long-term strategies for the Company, the Board also benefits from the experience, knowledge and perspective, which new directors may bring from the oversight of activities from a variety of economic and competitive environments, to effectively adapt to necessary changes.
• The Nomination and Remuneration Committee may source, shortlist and conduct inquiries into new candidates from appropriate nominations by the general shareholders and from the directors' database. The Committee may also seek assistance by engaging a professional headhunting firm to identify, evaluate and carry out due diligence on potential director candidates.
• The Nomination and Remuneration Committee identifies, reviews and assesses the qualifications of existing directors and potential candidates, before making recommendations to the Board for approval. The Committee shall consider a candidate’s background and experience, to ensure that a broad range of perspectives is represented on the Board.
Director Qualifications
1. Directors shall fulfil qualification requirements set out in the Public Limited Companies Act and the Company’s Articles of Association, with a strong record of ethical behaviour and professional conduct and shall not possess characteristics prohibited by SET regulations or by the Capital Market Supervisory Board.
2. Qualified directors shall be able to perform duties and express opinions independently and commit to devoting sufficient time to fulfil their roles and responsibilities.
3. A Director shall not hold a director position in a total of more than five (5) other public listed companies.
4. An Executive Director shall not hold a director position in a total of more than three (3) other public listed companies.
5. The Chief Executive Officer shall notify the Board of Directors, before taking the position of director at any other company.
6. The Company has adopted the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) of Thailand’s guidelines for determining Independent Director qualifications.
Did Any Independent Director Have a Business or Professional Relationship?
No
Evaluation of Board & Subcommittee Performance
Criteria for Evaluating Board Performance
The Nomination and Remuneration Committee and the Company Secretary conduct annual assessment of the effectiveness and performance of the Board, as a whole, of each Sub-Committee, including the Audit Committee, the Business Strategic Committee and the Nomination and Remuneration Committee, as well as of each individual Director.
The evaluation process is conducted by online self-assessment. The QR Code or link to access the questionnaires are provided to each director, in the second quarter, and the assessment is to be completed before the end of September, each year.
The scope of the self-assessment for the Board, as a whole, is as follows :
1. Board structure and director qualifications
2. Roles, duties and responsibilities
3. Effectiveness of Board meetings
4. Duties of directors
5. Relationship with management
6. Directors' self-development
7. Comments
The scope of the self-assessment for each Sub-Committee is as follows :
1. Roles, duties and responsibilities of the Committee
2. Committee structure and director qualifications
3. Effectiveness of Committee meetings
4. Comments
The scope of the self-assessment for each individual Director is as follows :
1. Board structure and director qualifications
2. Roles, duties and responsibilities of the director
3. Director meetings
4. Comments
Evaluation of Board Performance in the Past Year
In 2024, the Company conducted an annual performance assessment of the Board of Directors, each Sub-Committee and each individual Director, with the following results: Overall, the Board and Committees ran smoothly, with a harmonious balance of Board structure, Director qualifications and leadership. The organization of meetings was effective, providing good opportunities for open discussion and sharing of opinions. On an individual basis, the Company openly and humbly admits to having room for continuous improvement.
Evaluation Results
| Evaluated Body | Group — Carried Out? | Group — Grade / Average Score | Group — Grade / Full Score | Individual (Self-Assessment) — Carried Out? | Individual (Self-Assessment) — Grade / Average Score | Individual (Self-Assessment) — Grade / Full Score | Cross (Assessing Other Directors) — Carried Out? |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Board Of Director | Y | 3.87 | 4 | Y | 3.84 | 4 | N |
| Other Subcommittee | Y | 3.70 | 4 | N | N | ||
| Audit Committee | Y | 4 | 4 | N | N | ||
| Other Subcommittee | Y | 3.95 | 4 | N | N |
Subcommittees
Subcommittees
| Results of the Subcommittee's Duty Performance | Meetings — Introduction |
|---|---|
The important matters considered and discussed can be summarized, as follows Appointment of Directors, whose term of office has expired, and the Vacant Position The Nomination and Remuneration Committee annually assesses the effectiveness of each current director and evaluates the qualifications of potential candidates, in order to determine suitability for re-election at term rotation. The Committee understands the importance of the Board’s effectiveness and strives to maintain an appropriate balance of diversity, professional experience and skills on the Board. Each year, the Committee considers each director’s individual performance, past contribution, outside experiences and activities, as well as any Sub-Committee participation, and determines how the Directors’ experience and skills may continue to support the Company and the Board, both in current and future business.
The Nomination and Remuneration Committee reviews the CEO, Senior Management and Employee compensation budget, remuneration structure and benefit programs, and oversees human resource management. The Committee reviewed the necessary action taken to ensure compliance with the revised minimum wage, effective from 1st January 2024, by announcement from the Ministry of Labor, Thailand.
The Nomination and Remuneration Committee reviews and recommends the annual remuneration proposal for the Board of Directors and Sub-Committees, to the Board, taking into account business operating results throughout the year, together with Company goals, in order to incentivize attaining expected results.
The Nomination and Remuneration Committee reviewed the adequacy of and necessary changes for the Charter, to ensure the correct procedures are in place, necessary for the Committee to function efficiently, as so stipulated in the current compliance requirements, and obtained approval thereof from the Board of Directors.
| The Nomination and Remuneration Committee of Thai Optical Group Public Company Limited comprises (3) independent directors, who possess qualifications and knowledgeable expertise in various fields, plus Ms. Siriporn Phol-Uayporn, the Head of the HR Division, who Secretary to the Nomination and Remuneration Committee |
The important matters considered and discussed can be summarized, as follows Overseeing the development of Company strategy The Committee worked with the Chief Executive Officer and the Senior Management to oversee the development of the Company’s strategy, and to provide guidance for the strategic planning process, to ensure that the strategic implementation plan was developed, adhered to and embedded in the organization.
The Committee monitored and reviewed the Company’s progress against strategic goals, and provided feedback and advice on sales, marketing, distribution channels, production & supply chain management, and resource planning
The Committee worked with the Chief Executive Officer and the management team, to oversee the review and recommendation to the Board of certain significant strategic decisions, regarding the entry into new lines of business or products and related investments, as well as dispositions of businesses and assets.
The Committee reviewed risks and opportunities of the strategy, as identified by the Company’s strategic risk assessment and other processes and analyses the impact of emerging or evolving competitive activity, innovation, technology, governmental or legislative developments, and global economic conditions.
| The Business Strategic Committee of Thai Optical Group Public Company Limited comprises (4) directors, with business expertise in the industry, with Mr. Bancha Yongrithikul, Head of TOG Production, as the Secretary to the Business Strategic Committee. |
Meeting Attendance & Remuneration
Types of Remuneration of the Board of Directors
Clause 23 of the Company’s Article of Association provide that The Directors are entitled to receive remuneration from the Company in the form of rewards, meeting allowances, gratuities, bonuses or benefits in other manners as approved by the shareholders' meeting which may determine as a fixed number or as a criterion and can determine from time to time or wish it to be effective forever until they are changed and in addition, they can receive allowances and various welfare according to the Company's orders.
The Nomination and Remuneration Committee is responsible for considering the forms and criteria for directors’ remuneration and recommending these to the Board of Directors for review and subsequent proposal to the shareholders’ meeting.
In determining the directors’ remuneration for the Company, the Nomination and Remuneration Committee has evaluated comparable remuneration data from other listed companies within the same industry, as well as the duties and responsibilities of the directors and the Company’s previous practices.
Remuneration or Benefits Payable to the Board
| Metric | Amount (Baht) |
|---|---|
| Remunerations or benefits pending payment to the board of directors over the past year (baht) | 0 |
Supervision of Subsidiaries & Associated Companies
Does the Company Have Subsidiaries or Associated Companies?
Yes
Is There a Mechanism for Overseeing Subsidiaries and Associated Companies?
Yes
Mechanism for Overseeing Management of Subsidiaries
principle 3.6 : The Board of Directors ensures that the Company’s governance framework and policies extend to and are accepted by Subsidiary and other businesses, in which it has a significant investment as appropriate.
3.6.1 The Board ensures that the Company’s governance framework and policies extend to its Subsidiary, including written policies relating to :
(1) Appointment of directors in the subsidiary companies
(2) Supervision of the directors in the Subsidiary companies, to ensure management thereof is in accordance with the Company's policies, and in the best interests
of the Subsidiary companies
(3) Appropriate risk management for subsidiary companies
(4) Disclosure of financial information and performance, Related Transactions with Connected Persons, acquisition and disposition of assets, and other important transactions.
3.6.2 For businesses, in which the Company has or plans to hold a significant investment, shareholder agreements or other agreements shall be undertaken.
Oversight Mechanisms
| Mechanism |
|---|
| Sending representatives to act as directors, executives or controlling persons in proportion to shareholdings |
| Defining the scope of powers, duties and responsibilities of directors and executives who represent the company in setting important policies |
| Disclosure of financial information and operating results |
| Transactions between the Company and related persons |
| Acquisition or disposal of assets |
| Internal control system of the subsidiary operating the core business is appropriate and sufficient in the subsidiary operating the core business |
| Other important transactions |
Board Duty Performance — Overview
Board Duty Performance — Overall Description
The Board is committed to strong corporate governance, to promote the long-term interests of the Company and its shareholders. Over the years, we have actively been participating in various institutional assessment programs, conducted by organizations working in conjunction with the Stock Exchange of Thailand (SET), such as AGM Checklist Survey by the Thai Investors Association, Corporate Governance Report by the Thai Institute of Directors Association (IOD), and the Sustainability Investment List by the SET. We aim to better understand capital market regulators’ expectations, and investors’ views on corporate governance and ESG, to consistently review and implement updates and improvements.
Audit Committee Duty Performance
Results of the Audit Committee's Duty Performance in the Past Year
Review of financial reports: The Audit Committee together with the Chief Financial Officer and the Chief Accountant, Internal Auditor and Company’s Auditor have reviewed the comprehensive information in the 2024 financial reports of the Company and its Subsidiary, both quarterly and yearly. Having reviewed various issues concerning the essential accounting policies, changes within the previous year, possible future implications, minor irregular items, and remarks from the Auditor and Internal Auditor, the Audit Committee opines that the preparation of the Company and its Subsidiary financial reports is in accordance with generally accepted accounting standards. Adequate information has been disclosed in the financial statements, and no items have been found that may have a material impact on the financial statements.
Review of connected transactions: The Audit Committee has reviewed the connected transactions, which must comply with the SET and SEC’s rules and regulations on the disclosure of connected transaction information, which may pose conflicts of interest. In this regard, the Audit Committee opines that all connected transactions were fair and reasonable, according to the General Commercial Term Transactions, with no conflict of interest. There were no unusual items, and disclosure was sufficient.
Internal controls: The Company has an Internal Auditor, who reports to the Audit Committee. This function is responsible for objectively reviewing and evaluating the adequacy, effectiveness and quality of the system of internal controls and operating effectiveness of the Company’s business processes. The Committee approves an annual internal audit plan and monitors the activities and performance of the Company’s internal audit function, throughout the year, to ensure the plan objectives are executed and fulfilled. Review of legal compliance: The Audit Committee has reviewed and supervised the Company and its Subsidiaries, in the undertaking of business operations to comply with the Securities and Exchange Acts, SEC’s and SET’s regulations, and other legal acts involving the Company’s business. There have been no indications of non-compliance, and/or practices that are contrary to or inconsistent with applicable terms, regulations and laws.
Review of risk management: The Audit Committee reviewed the Company's and its Subsidiary’s risk management to ensure that there is an appropriate and effective risk management process, undertaken by the Risk Management Team. The Team consists of the Chief Executive Officer, as the chairman, and management across all departments, and is responsible for considering the structure, policies and framework of risk management. The risk assessment process is regularly conducted by assessing the changing business environment, to identify necessary counter measures for both the short and long terms. Material or possible emerging risks shall be periodically reported to relevant Sub-Committees and the Board of Directors.
Report on suspicious issues: The Audit Committee is responsible for reporting any findings or suspicions of transactions or actions that may have a material impact on the financial position or operating result of the Company, to the Board of Directors. In the past year, there was no incident or issue, indicating that such an event occurred.
Consideration of and proposal for Company auditor appointment for 2024 fiscal year: In the year 2024, the Audit Committee selected accounting auditors based on their independence, knowledge, ability, experience and performance, as well as the audit fee to be charged to the Company and the Subsidiary and presented their proposal to the Board of Directors for consideration and approval, at the Annual General Meeting of Shareholders. The general shareholders meeting agreed upon an approval resolution to appoint the Certified Public Accountants from the EY Office Limited, as Independent Certified External Auditors of the Company and the Subsidiary, in Thailand. The details on such roles are reported in the Important Other Information section of this annual report.
In summary, for the year 2024, the Audit Committee conducted its duties as stipulated in the Audit Committee Charter, by assessing the operations of the Company and its Subsidiary, with sufficient independence. The committee was of the opinion that the Company and the Subsidiaries were reliable, had prepared accurate financial reports on material matters, in accordance with generally accepted accounting standards. It was determined that there had been adequate disclosure of information. When entering into any connected transaction(s) that may have had conflicts of interest, the Company was in strict compliance with the law and the requirements of the SET and the SEC, as well as with all related laws, rules and regulations pertinent to business operations. In addition, the Company and the Subsidiaries demonstrated adequate risk management, and implemented good corporate governance in the organization. There were independent and qualified certified external auditors, and the Internal Auditor tracked, reviewed and ensured the audit and internal control system performed appropriately and effectively.

